What “folly” means

In architectural history, a folly is usually an ornamental or symbolic building whose practical purpose is limited or secondary. McCaig’s Tower fits parts of that description: it is monumental, visually dramatic and unfinished.

The nickname also responds to the gap between the ambition of the original scheme and the empty centre that survives. Yet the term can become misleading if it suggests there was no public purpose.

The project had practical intentions

Employment for local masons and artisans was a documented motive. The intended tower included a public viewing platform, and plans contemplated a museum and art gallery. McCaig also described the project as an ornament and acquisition for Oban.

Family commemoration was another important purpose. His will proposed statues of himself and relatives, and those provisions became the subject of legal challenge after his death.

A nickname, not an official title

“McCaig’s Tower” and “McCaig’s Monument” appear in heritage records. “McCaig’s Folly” remains a widely understood local and visitor nickname, but it is interpretive rather than an official designation.

The most balanced approach is to explain the nickname while retaining the complexity of the building’s purpose. The McCaig family and folly guide gives the fuller legal and historical context.

Sources and references

  1. Johnny Rodger, ‘McCaig’s Tower and a Scottish Monumental Tradition’Peer-reviewed academic article
  2. Historic Environment Scotland: Battery Hill, McCaig Monument (LB38814)Official designation record
  3. Trove / National Record of the Historic Environment: Oban, McCaig’s TowerNational heritage record